Tina Marinaccio

Integrative Functional Nutrition and Weight Loss Morristown NJ

  • Home
  • About Me
  • Services
  • Micronutrient/Antioxidant Testing
  • Metabolic Testing
  • Contact
  • Nutrition
  • Resume
  • Online Nutrition Assessment Questionnaire
  • Recipes
  • Buy Supplements
Roasted Baby Bella Mushrooms

Perfect Pan Roasted Caramelized Mushrooms

May 8, 2024 by Tina

Roasted Baby Bella Mushrooms
Roasted Baby Bella Mushrooms

Did you know mushrooms contain 80%-90% water? This can make them a little tricky to cook to a nice meaty texture without having them get soggy from steaming in their own liquid

Follow these tips and tricks for perfect mushrooms every time

Instagram Tutorial

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Tina Marinaccio (@tina_integrative_dietitian)

Are Mushrooms Good For You?

Sliced Baby Bella Mushrooms
Sliced Baby Bella Mushrooms

Each variety of mushroom has its’ own unique health benefits, but generally mushrooms protect against certain cancers, help with weight loss, can be a good source of vitamin D, lower cholesterol, and help to boost immunity

They are low in calories, and can make a good replacement for meat when grilled or used in chili

White and brown foods have a bad rep, largely because of white flour and sugar, but many of these foods are nutritional powerhouses. Check out White and Brown Nutrition Powerhouses for benefits of these foods

What Seasonings Go Best With Mushrooms?

Mushrooms Garlic Rosemary
Mushrooms Garlic Rosemary

Anything in the garlic or onion family goes well with mushrooms. Herbs like sage, rosemary, thyme, and parsley are also good pairings

How to Avoid Soggy Mushrooms

Mushrooms are best when they are roasted and caramelized. They will be cooked through but retain a nice meaty texture. Regardless of the type of mushrooms you choose to cook, they have a very high water content which is released during the cooking process, which can make them soggy or mushy if not handled right

Follow These Tips and Your Mushrooms Will Come Out Perfect Every Time

Pan Roasted Caramelized Mushrooms
Pan Roasted Caramelized Mushrooms

When cleaning, use a damp towel or mushroom brush to remove dirt vs. soaking or rinsing in water.

Running water over the mushroom will just add more water to the dish, and the goal is to cook out the naturally occurring water in the mushrooms

Use a Large Sauté Pan

If you overcrowd your pan, the mushrooms will boil in the liquid they release

Preheat Your Pan Over Medium Heat and Preheat Cooking Fat

Medium high heat vs. low will help the mushrooms roast in the pan. If the pan heat is too low, the mushrooms will steam in their liquid. I like to use extra virgin olive oil, which is 100% fat. Many people like to use butter because of the rich flavor, but butter has about 20% naturally occurring water content. If you like buttery flavor, try a mix of extra virgin olive oil with some butter, and be mindful that you will want to roast any extra water out

When to Add Salt to Mushrooms

I add salt at the very end stage of cooking mushrooms. If you add it too early before they are browned and roasted, the salt will pull the water out making the mushrooms soggy. In this recipe, I am using tamari instead of salt. The same holds true whether using salt, broth, soy sauce, or tamari in that you will want to add it at the end. If you are using a salty liquid, stir it in quickly so it gets evenly distributed among the mushrooms and cook it off until the pan is dry

Can I Freeze Mushrooms

Because of the water content, if you freeze mushrooms, they will be soggy when you defrost them. It’s best to buy fresh, cook, store leftovers in the frig, and use within 3-5 days

What Can I Do With Cooked Mushrooms?

Burger Roasted Mushrooms Mozzarella
Burger Roasted Mushrooms Mozzarella

Add to a barley pilaf, polenta or pasta, soups, or top a burger or pizza. Roasted or grilled mushrooms make a great addition to sandwiches. You can pulse them in a mini chopper with some sundried tomatoes in oil for a delicious crostini spread as an appetizer. Sauté asparagus with mushrooms to make omelets for a quick mid-week supper.

Are Mushrooms Low Carb and Keto Friendly?

Burger With Roasted Mushrooms and Mozzarella
Burger With Roasted Mushrooms and Mozzarella

If you are carb conscious, mushrooms have the types of carbs that we do not break down. They do not impact blood sugar or insulin so are a perfect addition to a low carb or keto diet

Perfect Pan Roasted Caramelized Mushrooms

Plated Roasted Mushrooms
Plated Roasted Mushrooms

Makes One Cup Cooked

2 tbsp Extra Virgin Olive Oil, plus extra as needed

10 oz Baby Bella Mushrooms, cleaned and sliced ¼ inch pieces

3 large cloves garlic sliced

1 tbsp fresh chopped rosemary

1 tsp tamari or soy sauce

1 tsp balsamic vinegar

Ground pepper to taste

Preheat olive oil in a large skillet

Add sliced Baby Bella Mushrooms over medium high heat until they begin to soften, about 3 minutes

Add garlic slices and chopped rosemary, tossing to combine

If mushrooms are very dry, sprinkle in a little more olive oil

If mushrooms have begun to release liquid, no need to add more oil

Continue to sauté over medium high heat, stirring frequently, until mushrooms are brown, and pan liquid has evaporated

Sprinkle with tamari or soy sauce, and balsamic vinegar, and stir to evenly distribute, and cook down liquid

Stir in ground pepper

Taste to adjust seasonings if needed, and cook until mushrooms are caramelized

Filed Under: Dairy Free, Detox, Easy, Gluten Free, Gut Health, Healthy, Plant Based, Recipes, Sides Snacks Soups Salads Tagged With: 30 minute meals, anti inflammatory diet, caramelized, detox, gluten free, healthy, meal prep, mediterranean, mushrooms, roasted, vegan, vegetarian, weight loss

Recent Posts

  • Fresh Pea and Asparagus Salad
  • Butter Miso Cod For Fish Friday
  • 7 Tips to Avoid Vacation Weight Gain
  • Healthy Game Day Recipes
  • Easy Healthy Caesar Salad Dressing

Categories

  • Breakfast
  • Dairy Free
  • Dessert
  • Detox
  • Easy
  • Fish and Shellfish
  • Gluten Free
  • Gut Health
  • Healthy
  • Lamb
  • Mains
  • Plant Based
  • Pork
  • Poultry
  • Recipes
  • Sides Snacks Soups Salads
Tina giving a cooking demo


Open a FREE WholeScripts account.

Use Referral Code 10MARINACCIO for a 10% discount on all orders, and Practitioner Name: Marinaccio when setting up your account.







instagramFollow Me On Instagram
FacebookLike My Facebook Page
linkedinMy LinkedIn

Speaker Services

Cooking Classes

Nutrition

What is an RD?

Contact

© 2025 Tina Marinaccio · All Rights Reserved